AMERICA (CALIFORNIA AS AN ISLAND) – 1661

Publisher: Philipp Clüver
Price: £250
Publication Date: 1661
Edition: Not stated
Format: Copper engraving
Condition: In very good condition, unframed
Sheet Size: 25cm x 37.7cm

Condition:

Published in Leiden, Germany. Edition identified by ‘pag. 666’ in the top right hand corner. Sheet Size: 37.7cm x 25cm. Original fold lines. Very minor age-spots. Age-toning to the paper. Reverse is blank with age toning and minor marks. In very good condition overall. California is shown as a large island, the north-west coast of America is not identified and none of the Great Lakes are visible. New Zealand is shown as a single coastline.

Location: Map Drawer C: FS: Folder M2000 002546

Philipp Clüver: A Short Biography

Philipp Clüver, often Latinised as Philippus Cluverius, was a prominent German geographer and historian of the early modern period, celebrated as one of the founders of historical geography. His work bridged the gap between classical scholarship and emerging geographical sciences, influencing the development of geographical thought in Europe during the 17th century.

Early Life

Clüver was born in Danzig (modern-day Gdańsk, Poland) on 25 February 1580. His father was a merchant, and Philipp was initially encouraged to follow a similar career path. However, he displayed an early aptitude for classical studies and a keen interest in exploration, which would shape his future pursuits. After his father’s death, Clüver embarked on extensive travels throughout Europe, an experience that deeply informed his geographical work.

Education and Travels

Clüver initially studied law at the University of Leiden, in the Netherlands. However, his interest soon shifted to classical literature, geography, and history. Seeking a deeper understanding of the world, he travelled extensively, visiting Germany, England, Scotland, France, and Italy. His journeys allowed him to observe the landscapes, cultures, and historical sites of these regions, which became critical elements in his later works.

Clüver’s exploration of the Mediterranean and classical ruins, particularly in Greece and Italy, deepened his appreciation of ancient civilisations. His time in England also exposed him to the works of Renaissance geographers, which further honed his methodological approach.

Career and Contributions

In 1615, Clüver was appointed as a geographer at the University of Leiden. It was during this period that he produced his most significant works, synthesising classical historical sources with geographical observations. He is perhaps best known for his Introductio in Universam Geographiam (Introduction to Universal Geography), published posthumously in 1624. This work was a landmark in geographical literature, combining descriptions of the physical world with historical and cultural insights.

Clüver’s approach was heavily influenced by classical texts, particularly those of Strabo, Ptolemy, and Pliny the Elder. He sought to integrate ancient geographic knowledge with contemporary observations, creating a historical narrative of places and their peoples. His work covered not only Europe but also parts of Asia and Africa, reflecting the global ambitions of early modern geography.

Legacy

Clüver’s blend of historical analysis and geographical study earned him the title of the “father of historical geography.” His methods emphasised the importance of understanding the historical context of regions, influencing later geographers and historians. His Introductio became a standard reference in European education for over a century, with numerous editions and translations.

Despite his achievements, Clüver’s reliance on classical sources sometimes led to inaccuracies, as his commitment to ancient texts occasionally outweighed contemporary evidence. Nevertheless, his pioneering efforts laid the groundwork for a more analytical and interdisciplinary approach to geography.

Personal Life

Details of Clüver’s personal life are sparse. He remained unmarried and appeared wholly dedicated to his scholarly pursuits. His death on 31 December 1622 in Leiden marked the end of a life devoted to intellectual exploration. He was buried in Leiden, where he had spent the most productive years of his career.

Conclusion

Philipp Clüver’s contributions to geography and historical scholarship remain a cornerstone in the history of cartography and geographical thought. His innovative fusion of classical studies with geographical enquiry exemplifies the intellectual currents of the early modern period, and his legacy endures in the field of historical geography.

California As An Island: A Short History

The depiction of California as an island is one of the most fascinating and persistent errors in the history of cartography. This misconception, which spanned over a century, reflects the challenges of early exploration, the reliance on speculative reports, and the tendency of cartographers to perpetuate errors through replication.

Origins of the Myth

The belief that California was an island is thought to have originated from early Spanish explorations of the Americas in the 16th century. Spanish explorers such as Hernán Cortés and others who navigated the Baja California Peninsula misinterpreted the Gulf of California (Sea of Cortez) as a strait separating California from the mainland. Early reports, coupled with the lack of thorough inland exploration, reinforced the idea that California was detached from the rest of North America.

A critical factor in the origin of this misconception was the romanticised narrative of a mythical island of California. This idea drew from a novel by Garci Rodríguez de Montalvo, who described California as a paradisiacal island inhabited by warrior women and abundant in gold. The blending of myth and incomplete geographical knowledge contributed to the cartographic error.

Development and Proliferation

By the early 17th century, the notion of California as an island became widely accepted among European cartographers. This acceptance was not necessarily due to new discoveries but rather the repetition of earlier maps and descriptions. The error first appeared in print on maps by European cartographers who relied on reports from Spanish expeditions.

Prominent maps of the 17th century perpetuated the island depiction. These included the works of Nicolas Sanson, a French cartographer whose 1650 maps solidified California as a large, elongated island stretching parallel to the western coast of North America. Dutch cartographers, such as Johannes Vingboons, also adopted the concept, ensuring its broad dissemination across Europe.

The persistence of the error can be attributed to the cartographic practice of the time. Maps were often copied and adapted without verification of their geographical accuracy. Once the island of California became a standard feature, it was repeated across countless maps, creating a feedback loop that sustained the myth.

Iconic Maps

The 17th century saw the production of numerous maps depicting California as an island. These maps were not uniform in their representation; some showed California as a narrow, elongated landmass, while others depicted it as a more compact island. These variations reflected the speculative nature of cartography at the time, as well as the influence of different sources.

Maps by notable cartographers such as Vincenzo Coronelli in Italy, Henricus Hondius in the Netherlands, and John Speed in England popularised the island concept. Coronelli’s maps, in particular, were highly detailed and decorative, making them influential in shaping public and scholarly perceptions.

Decline of the Myth

The error began to unravel in the late 17th and early 18th centuries as explorers and missionaries provided more accurate accounts of the region. Eusebio Francisco Kino, a Jesuit missionary, played a crucial role in dispelling the myth. His overland explorations of Baja California in the 1690s demonstrated that the peninsula was connected to the mainland.

Despite Kino’s findings, the transition to accurate depictions of California was gradual. Some cartographers continued to depict California as an island well into the early 18th century, either out of scepticism or adherence to older maps. However, by the mid-18th century, the notion of California as an island had largely been abandoned in favour of its proper representation as part of the North American continent.

Legacy

The story of California as an island is emblematic of the challenges and limitations of early cartography. It underscores the influence of mythology, speculation, and the circulation of unverified information in shaping geographical knowledge. The error has since become a subject of fascination among historians and collectors of antique maps, serving as a reminder of the evolving nature of human understanding.

Today, maps depicting California as an island are prized for their historical significance and aesthetic value. They stand as enduring artefacts of an era when the boundaries between fact and fiction were often blurred in the pursuit of exploration and knowledge.

SHOP WITH CONFIDENCE AT HORNSEYS

At Hornseys, we are dedicated to offering items that uphold the highest standards of quality and authenticity. Our collection of artwork is carefully curated to ensure that each item we offer is authentic, collated, and complete.

Here’s what sets us apart:

• Authenticity and Provenance: Each map is researched and verified for authenticity.
• Expert Curation: We wholly own all our artworks. We trust our taste and have invested heavily in it. We have confidence in all artwork that we offer for sale.
• Customer Satisfaction: We strive to provide an exceptional customer experience, from detailed descriptions and provenance to secure and prompt delivery of your purchase.
• Returns Policy: We offer an unconditional guarantee on every item. If, however, you wish to make a return, artworks may be sent back to us within fourteen days of receipt for whatever reason. We request that we are notified in advance if you wish to do so. They must be returned to us in the same condition as they were sent for a full refund.

OUR COMMITMENT TO QUALITY AND SERVICE

Understanding the value and rarity of these items, we ensure that every aspect of your purchase meets the highest standards of quality and service. This includes:

• Free Expedited, Tracked, and Insured Delivery within the UK: Ensuring that your artwork arrives safely and promptly.
• Fully-Insured Worldwide Delivery: Offering peace of mind for international collectors with reliable and secure shipping options.

EXPLORE OUR COLLECTION

Visit Hornseys today to explore our fine collection of maps and other artworks. Whether you are an avid collector or looking for a special gift, our selection offers something truly unique. Located since 1976 in Ripon in the picturesque Yorkshire Dales, we are recognised as a destination gallery for tastefully curated artwork, rare maps, design, and fine books.